Dealers / Madison, WI
120 dealers77 graded
Car Dealer Grades in Madison, WI
Every new and used car dealer around Madison, graded A, B, C or F from what past buyers said in public reviews.
77 of the 120 car dealers around Madison have enough public reviews to grade. 29 percent earn an A and 5 percent an F.
At a glance
- 83 percent grade A or B, against 62 percent nationally
- 5 percent F, fewer than the 16 percent national rate
- Top graded brand store Porsche Madison
- Top graded used lot Smart Buys Cars
29%Grade A
55%Grade B
12%Grade C
5%Grade F
77 shown
ASmart Buys CarsUsed car dealer · 5901 Odana Rd, Madison5.092 reviews0%complaintsAPorsche MadisonPorsche dealer · 2300 Rimrock Rd, Madison4.9394 reviews1.5%complaintsAFarris Auto Service and SalesUsed car dealer · 212 W Cottage Grove Rd, Cottage Grove4.9218 reviews1.8%complaintsALake City Auto LLCUsed car dealer · 526 Commercial Ave, Sun Prairie4.9219 reviews2.7%complaintsATrust N Ride Auto Sales & RepairUsed car dealer · 3773 E Washington Ave, Madison4.9149 reviews2.7%complaintsAApex AutoUsed car dealer · 3074 E Washington Ave #4339, Madison4.980 reviews1.2%complaintsAGoben CarsUsed car dealer · 7613 Century Ave, Middleton4.83,509 reviews3.2%complaintsADon Miller Subaru EastSubaru dealer · 5401 High Crossing Blvd, Madison4.81,918 reviews3.1%complaintsADon Miller Subaru WestSubaru dealer · 5822 Odana Rd, Madison4.82,111 reviews3.4%complaintsAMINI of MadisonMINI dealer · 310 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.8947 reviews3.1%complaintsAZimbrick AcuraAcura dealer · 7525 Century Ave, Middleton4.8852 reviews3.2%complaintsAZimbrick Buick GMC EastsideGMC dealer · 5402 High Crossing Blvd, Madison4.82,789 reviews4.3%complaintsAZimbrick Volkswagen of MadisonVolkswagen dealer · 1430 N Stoughton Rd, Madison4.81,892 reviews4.3%complaintsAZimbrick NissanNissan dealer · 5330 High Crossing Blvd, Madison4.72,022 reviews4.3%complaintsAZimbrick Hyundai EastsideHyundai dealer · 5433 Wayne Terrace, Madison4.72,265 reviews4.5%complaintsAZimbrick ChevroletChevrolet dealer · 1877 W Main St, Sun Prairie4.71,341 reviews5.2%complaintsAAudi MadisonAudi dealer · 2400 Rimrock Rd, Madison4.71,169 reviews5.8%complaintsABMW of MadisonBMW dealer · 320 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.72,204 reviews6.1%complaintsABergstrom Lexus of MadisonLexus dealer · 8000 Airport Rd, Middleton4.71,000 reviews6.2%complaintsAByrider MadisonUsed car dealer · 5234 High Crossing Blvd, Madison4.72,500 reviews7.2%complaintsAFields Volvo Cars MadisonVolvo dealer · 504 E Badger Rd #103, Madison4.71,124 reviews7%complaintsAZimbrick INFINITIInfiniti dealer · 1601 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.7313 reviews6.1%complaintsBCar Smart of MadisonUsed car dealer · 3074 E Washington Ave, Madison5.026 reviews0%complaintsBMerit Motors AutoUsed car dealer · 6701 Seybold Rd, Madison5.025 reviews0%complaintsBGreat Motors Auto Sales LLCUsed car dealer · 3586 E Washington Ave, Madison5.023 reviews0%complaintsBH&S AutomotiveUsed car dealer · 902 Atlas Ave, Madison4.936 reviews2.8%complaintsBZimbrick Automotive GroupUsed car dealer · 7525 Century Ave, Middleton4.675 reviews2.7%complaintsBLuxor Auto SalesUsed car dealer · 6790 Watts Rd, Madison4.773 reviews6.9%complaintsBKayser FordFord dealer · 2303 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.62,651 reviews7%complaintsBSmart Motors ToyotaToyota dealer · 5901 Odana Rd, Madison4.63,571 reviews7.1%complaintsBDrive Auto - Madison, WIUsed car dealer · 5632 Odana Rd, Madison4.823 reviews4.3%complaintsBZimbrick Volkswagen of MiddletonVolkswagen dealer · 7505 Century Ave, Middleton4.6769 reviews7%complaintsBWilde East Towne HondaHonda dealer · 5555 High Crossing Blvd, Madison4.63,125 reviews7.9%complaintsBDon Miller Subaru West Pre-Owned CenterUsed car dealer · 5812 Odana Rd, Madison4.728 reviews3.6%complaintsBRuss Darrow Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM of MadisonUsed car dealer · 3502 Lancaster Dr, Madison4.62,830 reviews8%complaintsBEast Madison ToyotaToyota dealer · 3501 Lancaster Dr, Madison4.62,533 reviews8.3%complaintsBKayser Used CarsUsed car dealer · 2301 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.746 reviews6.5%complaintsBZimbrick HondaHonda dealer · 1601 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.61,307 reviews8.9%complaintsBGoben CarsUsed car dealer · 3415 Parmenter St, Middleton4.61,971 reviews9%complaintsBBergstrom Cadillac of MadisonCadillac dealer · 1200 Applegate Rd, Madison4.6382 reviews8.6%complaintsBSchoepp MotorsUsed car dealer · 3440 Tribeca Dr, Middleton4.62,072 reviews9.6%complaintsBSmart Motors Used CarsUsed car dealer · 5710 Odana Rd, Madison4.6127 reviews8.7%complaintsBGolden CarsUsed car dealer · 2121 N Stoughton Rd, Madison4.679 reviews7.6%complaintsBGenesis of MadisonGenesis dealer · 1809 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.6146 reviews9.6%complaintsBZimbrick Buick GMC WestUsed car dealer · 1601 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.5842 reviews9.6%complaintsBZimbrick Hyundai WestHyundai dealer · 1809 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.51,249 reviews9.8%complaintsBKunes Mad City Mitsubishi of MadisonMitsubishi dealer · 920 Ann St, Madison4.54,560 reviews11.2%complaintsBDon Miller Dodge Chrysler Jeep Ram FIATUsed car dealer · 5802 Odana Rd, Madison4.51,025 reviews11.1%complaintsBCarHop Auto Sales and FinanceUsed car dealer · 2957 Packers Ave, Madison4.5123 reviews10.6%complaintsBStark on the BeltlineUsed car dealer · 6806 Seybold Rd, Madison4.5537 reviews12.3%complaintsBDon Miller of MadisonUsed car dealer · 5739 Tokay Blvd, Madison4.460 reviews8.3%complaintsBKayser Automotive GroupUsed car dealer · 2303 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.4212 reviews9.4%complaintsBBergstrom Chevrolet of MiddletonChevrolet dealer · 3605 Tribeca Dr, Middleton4.4882 reviews10.5%complaintsBRuss Darrow Kia of MadisonKia dealer · 6525 Odana Rd, Madison4.42,843 reviews11.9%complaintsBMiddleton FordFord dealer · 7520 Century Ave, Middleton4.41,188 reviews12.1%complaintsBBergstrom Chevrolet of MadisonChevrolet dealer · 1345 Applegate Rd, Madison4.41,086 reviews12.2%complaintsBRuss Darrow Mazda of MadisonMazda dealer · 2302 W Beltline Hwy, Madison4.41,483 reviews12.9%complaintsBEmblem Pre-ownedUsed car dealer · 3505 E Washington Ave, Madison4.4195 reviews13.9%complaintsBSchoepp Motors NortheastUsed car dealer · 1518 N Stoughton Rd, Madison4.4341 reviews14.1%complaintsBMetro Ford of MadisonFord dealer · 5422 Wayne Terrace, Madison4.41,241 reviews14.5%complaintsBOliver MotorsUsed car dealer · 345 Linnerud Dr, Sun Prairie4.446 reviews13%complaintsBEaston Motors EZ Credit of Sun PrairieUsed car dealer · 1040 Windsor St, Sun Prairie4.4182 reviews14.3%complaintsBWheels Deals INCUsed car dealer · 6701 Seybold Rd #004, Madison4.429 reviews13.8%complaintsBCarMaxUsed car dealer · 6601 Odana Rd, Madison4.2855 reviews15%complaintsCQuality Cars for LessUsed car dealer · 4515 Cottage Grove Rd, Madison4.3103 reviews16.5%complaintsCGerman Auto House LLCUsed car dealer · 3000 Rimrock Rd, Fitchburg4.3139 reviews16.6%complaintsCCampus CarsUsed car dealer · 1337 Regent St, Madison4.232 reviews18.8%complaintsCLot 51 Auto SalesUsed car dealer · 3901 Dempsey Rd, Madison4.2126 reviews17.5%complaintsCMetro Kia of MadisonKia dealer · 5442 Wayne Terrace, Madison4.2744 reviews18.6%complaintsCMobilityWorksUsed car dealer · 222 Linnerud Dr, Sun Prairie4.132 reviews18.8%complaintsCA to Z Auto Sports LLCUsed car dealer · 1415 Pflaum Rd, Madison4.1182 reviews20.3%complaintsCCapital Auto ClinicUsed car dealer · 2412 Packers Ave, Madison4.189 reviews21.3%complaintsCToby's Auto Sales LTDUsed car dealer · 1004 Fish Hatchery Rd, Madison4.075 reviews20%complaintsFMiddleton Auto MartUsed car dealer · 3012 Parmenter St, Middleton3.924 reviews29.2%complaintsFSteve's Auto Sales of MadisonUsed car dealer · 1619 S Stoughton Rd, Madison3.8154 reviews28.6%complaintsFSchoepp Motors EastUsed car dealer · 2402 S Stoughton Road Service Rd, Madison3.5113 reviews36.3%complaintsFCapitol Auto CreditUsed car dealer · 3100 E Washington Ave, Madison2.674 reviews56.8%complaints
43 more lots with fewer than 20 reviews, not graded
- Auto Works 3715 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison · 608-222-3119 · 19 reviews
- Mad Motors 2317 S Stoughton Rd, Madison · 608-470-7903 · 18 reviews
- MD Motors Inc 246 W Main St, Sun Prairie · 608-318-0202 · 15 reviews
- Truck Sales at U-Haul 22 Atlas Ct, Madison · 608-221-4277 · 12 reviews
- Brightwork Auto 5864 Easy St, Waunakee · 608-358-4523 · 11 reviews
- Dependable Auto Sport LLC 4290 Hoepker Rd, Madison · 608-217-4010 · 11 reviews
- Komfort Autos 225 Paoli St, Verona · 608-698-9020 · 11 reviews
- Guarantee Autos LLC 6701 Seybold Rd Suite 219, Madison · 608-283-9482 · 7 reviews
- Monona Auto Sales LLC 925 E Broadway, Monona · 608-640-0400 · 7 reviews
- Total auto 4717 Femrite Dr, Madison · 608-665-0045 · 7 reviews
- Zimbrick Used Vehicles 7525 Century Ave, Middleton · 608-807-1125 · 7 reviews
- Ace Automotives 3566 E Washington Ave, Madison · 6 reviews
- Spiegel GARAGE 1222 US-14, Oregon · 608-218-4499 · 6 reviews
- Don Miller Subaru East Pre-owned 5339 Wayne Terrace, Madison · 608-258-3640 · 5 reviews
- Packers Auto & Cycle LLC 2518 Packers Ave, Madison · 608-721-0754 · 5 reviews
- Zimbrick Volkswagen of Madison Pre-Owned 1707 N Stoughton Rd Ste 100, Madison · 608-230-0747 · 4 reviews
- Car Connection Madison 901 W Broadway, Monona · 608-698-4992 · 3 reviews
- Luxor Auto sales East 2652 E Washington Ave, Madison · 608-960-5413 · 3 reviews
- Zimbrick Eastside Economy Korner 3533 Benjamin Dr, Madison · 608-241-1122 · 3 reviews
- Madison Auto Sales 4281 Acker Rd, Madison · 608-852-4123 · 2 reviews
- Zimbrick of Madison Used on Stoughton Road 1707 N Stoughton Rd, Madison · 608-241-5201 · 2 reviews
- Classic Auto Sales Dealership LLC. 2410 Mustang Way, Madison · 1 review
- M & M Car Sales 3720 Milwaukee St, Madison · 608-241-8880 · 1 review
- Madison Victoria Motors 3566 E Washington Ave, Madison · 608-852-9341 · 1 review
- Right Way Auto LLC 832 S Park St, Madison · 608-234-8609 · 1 review
- Smart Auto Finance 6507 Odana Rd, Madison · 1 review
- Wonder Motors 3562 E Washington Ave, Madison · 608-467-2203 · 1 review
- 390autosales 6701 Seybold Rd, Madison · 0 reviews
- Aurora Modern Auto Sales & Transportation LLC. 2222 Eagle Dr, Middleton · 608-410-8534 · 0 reviews
- Auto dealership in Madison 2957 Packers Ave, Madison · 608-709-1712 · 0 reviews
- Autotec of WI, LLC 1701 S Stoughton Road Service Rd, Madison · 608-249-4400 · 0 reviews
- Exo World Motors 6300 Enterprise Ln Ste 208, Madison · 608-882-6169 · 0 reviews
- Gary Sells Cars 5901 Odana Rd, Madison · 608-354-3685 · 0 reviews
- Mark Andrew 7002 Tree Ln, Madison · 405-517-1277 · 0 reviews
- Preston Auto Sales Dealership LLC. 312 Linnerud Dr, Sun Prairie · 608-979-7087 · 0 reviews
- Russ Darrow Group 2302 W Beltline Hwy, Madison · 888-225-5363 · 0 reviews
- Tom McConnell at Zimbrick Eastside 5402 High Crossing Blvd, Madison · 608-316-8994 · 0 reviews
- Truck Sales at U-Haul 602 W Washington Ave, Madison · 608-256-3743 · 0 reviews
- Truck Sales at U-Haul 522 W Platte Dr, Madison · 608-833-6610 · 0 reviews
- Truck Sales at U-Haul 4716 Verona Rd, Madison · 608-807-0402 · 0 reviews
- Truck Sales at U-Haul 2701 Packers Ave, Madison · 608-535-8419 · 0 reviews
- Tugaway Autosales 510 Linnerud Dr, Sun Prairie · 608-834-2470 · 0 reviews
- Used Cars Madison 5901 Odana Rd, Madison · 608-440-9474 · 0 reviews
Common questions
Who are the best car dealers in Madison?
Of 77 graded dealers around Madison, 29 percent earn an A. The list above is sorted best first. An A means a long record of happy buyers and very few one or two star reviews. Filter by A to see only those.
How many car dealers around Madison get an F?
5 percent of graded dealers here, against 16 percent across all 109 metros we cover. An F means a heavy share of past buyers left one or two stars.
Why are some dealers not graded?
A grade needs 20 or more public reviews. 43 lots in this area have fewer, so they are listed with their address and phone but not graded yet.
Can you inspect a car at a Madison dealership?
Yes. PPI Auto inspects cars on dealer lots around Madison. We run 122 points, a full OBD-II scan and a road test, and send the report and photos the same day.
Buying in Madison? Book a pre purchase inspection in Madison, WI, see how the grade works, and how to check out a dealer.
A good grade covers the dealer, not the car. Have the car checked before you sign.
Found a car at a Madison lot?
We inspect it on the lot before you sign.