Paul Miller Toyota
Buyer's Guide grade B · 2,276 public reviews · September 2026
Paul Miller Toyota earns a B. 2,276 public reviews average 4.5 stars and 11 percent are one or two stars. That ranks it above 56 percent of graded dealers around Newark.
At a glance
- Mostly happy buyers, with a small share of complaints.
- Complaint share 11 percent, level with the 11.5 percent typical near Newark
- Reviewers mention car buying experience most, in 189 reviews
- Closed Sundays · Toyota dealer
Why It Got a B
The star average is 4.5 from 2,276 public reviews. After the grade pulls it toward the national average, it counts as 4.49. 11 percent of reviews are one or two stars. To reach an A it would need an adjusted rating of 4.6 and a complaint share of 8 percent or less. How the grade works.
How the Stars Break Down
What Reviewers Talk About
The subjects that come up most in public reviews of this dealer, with how many reviews mention each one.
Buying From Paul Miller Toyota
Paul Miller Toyota sells new Toyota vehicles and usually takes trade ins, so its used lot is a mix of brands. A certified car from the brand program comes with a factory backed warranty. A used car that is not certified is sold on the same terms as any other used car, so read the window sticker. How certified cars work.
Whatever the grade, the grade is about the dealer. The car is its own question. Ask the dealer if an independent inspection is allowed before you sign. A good lot says yes.
Dealer Details
| Address | 12 US-46, Pine Brook, NJ 07058 |
|---|---|
| Phone | 973-287-4050 |
| Website | paulmillertoyota.com |
| Listed features | Car wash, Oil changes, Service department, Sells used vehicles, Checks, Credit cards, Debit cards, Phone pay |
| Type | Toyota dealer |
Hours
| Monday | 9 AM to 8 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 9 AM to 8 PM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM to 8 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM to 8 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM to 8 PM |
| Saturday | 9 AM to 7 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Common Questions
Is Paul Miller Toyota a good dealer?
Can I get a car at Paul Miller Toyota inspected before I buy?
How is the grade worked out?
Is Paul Miller Toyota open on Sunday?
Other Graded Dealers Nearby
Buyers Also Look At
Grades update when public reviews do. Is this your dealership and something here is out of date? Tell us. See every graded dealer in Newark, NJ. Found a car here? Book a pre purchase inspection in Newark, NJ before you sign.
Inspect it on the lot
We check the car at Paul Miller Toyota before you sign.
951-267-8500Call nowInspect a car at Paul Miller Toyota
Send the car details and we will call you back.
The grade covers the dealer. We check the car.
122 points, a full scan and a road test, on the lot, same day report.