Signs of a Bad Car Dealer to Watch For

The biggest sign of a bad car dealer is a lot that will not let an outside mechanic inspect the car before you buy it.

Red Flags You Can See Before You Go

Some warning signs show up before you ever set foot on the lot. Start in our directory and look at the dealer grade. An F means past buyers left a low adjusted rating or a high share of one and two star reviews, or both.

Then look at whether the listing is claimed. A claimed listing means the business has taken control of its public profile. In our data, unclaimed listings grade F 42 percent of the time. Claimed listings grade F only 13 percent of the time. That does not mean claiming a listing makes a dealer better. It may just mean a dealer who cares about its listing also cares about its buyers. Either way, an unclaimed listing is worth a closer look.

Review Words That Point to Trouble

The words buyers use tell you a lot. We checked how often certain words show up in reviews of A dealers and F dealers.

• Scam shows up for 7.7 percent of F dealers and 0.1 percent of A dealers.
• Lemon shows up for 7.7 percent of F dealers and 0.1 percent of A dealers.
• Check engine light shows up for 5.5 percent of F dealers and 0 percent of A dealers.
• Title problems show up for 2.5 percent of F dealers and 0 percent of A dealers.
• Bait and switch shows up for 0.6 percent of F dealers and 0 percent of A dealers.

One review with one of these words is not a verdict. A pattern of them is. Our guide on review words that separate good and bad dealers goes deeper.

The Biggest Flag Is No Inspection

A good dealer has nothing to hide. If you ask to have an outside mechanic look at the car and the lot says no, that is the loudest warning you will get. It does not matter how nice the staff is or how clean the car looks.

Some lots say their own shop already checked the car. That is not the same thing. Their mechanic works for them. Others say insurance rules will not allow it. A mobile inspection happens right on the lot, and most good dealers allow it without a fuss. If the answer is still no, walk away.

Red Flags on the Lot

These are things any buyer can spot in person or on the phone.

• They push you to sign today because the deal ends tonight.
• They will not give you the out the door price in writing.
• They talk only about the monthly payment, never the price.
• The title is not on hand, or they are vague about where it is.
• A newer car is sold as is with no clear reason.
• The car in person does not match the photos or the ad.
• They want a deposit before you have seen the car.
• They add fees at the desk you never heard about before.

Any one of these can have an honest reason. Two or three together should make you leave.

Why Payment Talk Is a Warning

A lot that only talks about the monthly payment is steering you away from the price. A lower payment can come from a longer loan, a higher rate, or add ons tucked into the deal. You end up paying more and it feels like less.

Always ask for the full out the door price first. That number includes the car, taxes, title, registration and every fee. Our guide on car dealer fees shows what belongs in it and what does not.

Title Problems and As Is Sales

If the lot does not have the title in hand, you may wait weeks to register the car. In the worst cases, the car may still have a loan on it from the last owner. Ask to see the title before you pay.

Also check what kind of title it is. A salvage or rebuilt title changes the value of the car a lot. Our post on salvage titled cars explains what to watch for.

As is sales are legal and common on older cars. But a nearly new car sold as is, with no reason given, deserves a question. Ask why.

How an Inspection Helps

Our used car inspection covers 122 points, a full OBD-II scan with readiness monitors, a road test, and tire and brake measurements, with photos. We come to the lot. You do not need to be there, and you get the report the same day.

Common Questions

Get the Car Inspected